History -- 1998 to Present -- Music's Grand Spiral O' Death --

DRM (and other doomed ideas) -- 2001

Please note that most dates on this page link to articles in the Boycott-RIAA news archives or other publications.
The date shown is when the article was posted and not necessarily the day the events described took place.

January 2 -- First International Digital, Inc. (FID) and Songdog Network, Inc have announced a new twist to MP3 technology with the announcement of MP3i technology. The new technology is reported to allow for protective control over the file format, along with allowing more advanced features in playback then a typical MP3. The technolgy's "secure synchronized interactivity" of graphics during playback allows for the display of the song's lyrics, images, or advertisements as the song plays. The technology is reported to also feature a robust but easy to use encryption/decryption scheme along with unique user-specific transaction ID's, something that may turn some users off to the new technology.

January 16 -- Word has it that Princeton University computer science professor Edward Felten, who recently participated in a group which claims to have cracked SMDI (the Secure Digital Music Initiative), is now being silenced over fear of litigation.

But who and what is Professor Felton exactly afraid of? After all, the group working with the professor flat out refused to participate in the recent "Hack SDMI Challenge" so it would be able to talk publicly about its results, and not be locked in a non-disclosure agreement. It seems that even considering this, there still could be potential problems if the professor goes public with his results.

Under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, the companies backing the Secure Digital Music Initiative may very well be able to go after him and his team if he publishes his results to the public.

For now, following the advice of his legal counsel, Professor Felten stays silent.

January 22 -- IBM has stated that they will be releasing a new version of their anti-music piracy software, upping the ante in the ever growing fight for a working digital rights management solution for the recording industry.

While exact details are not available at the time of this story, the service works in this manner. IBM's new software solution still allows unlimited transfer between users, but placed in effect built-in restrictions. These "built-in restrictions" would permit the next person in line attempting to listen to the peer-to-peer or otherwise shared music to only play back the music once, or for the first 30 seconds of the song, a setting controlled by the digital music copyright holder of the music being shared.

The new software also features the ability to limit playback by region, much like that of current DVD technology. IBM is wise to admit that while the software offers quite a bit of that recording industry executives have been demanding in a copyright protective digital rights management software package, it is certainly not hacker proof.

The company has stated that is working with several companies the likes of Real Networks and MusicMatch Jukebox to offer built in plug-ins for direct sales and various payback options to copyright holders directly from the players in the future.

February 4 -- While the management of digital audio delivery online is something that Microsoft been aiming to control for sometime since the inception of Windows Media, it seems Microsoft has been building some new features into the Windows operating system which further assist in giving copyright holders security.

The "Secure Audio Path" technology scrambles the audio output from a PC's soundcard, thus eliminating the ability to record the audio at that point. This technology is already present in the "WindowsME" or Windows Millennium edition of the Windows OS.

Existing users of Windows Media Player have already seen some of what Microsoft has in mind for their future digital rights management solution. The player features an advanced level of security found in a lot of competitive DRM solutions. Some of these features include the ability for a limited amount of playback time and the ability to force users to obtain licenses in order for digital media playback to be enabled. While these are necessary evils in the ever growing digital entertainment revolution, changing some of the hardware capability of the end user's system may be going a bit to far, at least in the minds of the end users I am sure.

One thing is for certain however, whatever Microsoft has in mind to enforce for their digital rights management solution they are already working on implementing. Most likely, the resulting DRM solution is something that the average user will certainly not be aware of at all.

The fine lines of privacy vs. piracy are growing thinner.

February 8 -- Intel has unleashed a new set of API's (application programming interface) for their "Peer-to-Peer Trusted Library", allowing developers to pack in support for peer authentication, encryption, digital signatures and secure storage of files. Intel hopes to provide the P2P (peer-to-peer) development community with a method of securing applications being developed for P2P file exchange. Thus, allowing the control of content distributed through these systems.

Intel has been a large supporter of P2P technologies for quite some time, recognizing the next level of networking and online distribution as a large key to the future of online business. Intel has been using internal forms of P2P file sharing since the early 1990's, and has recently formed the peer-to-peer group www.peer-to-peerwg.org to attempt to draft standards for the future of the technology.

April 12 -- Microsoft Corp. and RealNetworks Inc. are working to together in order to steer music lovers away from the very popular MP3 format. Instead, the companies are encouraging users to use proprietary software formats. Microsoft and RealNetworks say that the audio sound will be significantly better but will also make it harder to share copyright-protected songs.

The Wall Street Journal is reporting that Microsoft plans to severely limit the quality of music that can be recorded as an MP3 file using software built into the next version of its personal-computer operating system, Windows XP. On the other hand, music recorded with the software company's own format, Windows Media Audio, will sound clearer and require far less storage space on a computer.

April 20 -- Record labels and the RIAA were forcing Napster to make a move on their current stand over blocking copyright-infringed songs. The pressure worked because early today Napster Inc. announced it licensed privately held Relatable's acoustic fingerprinting technology to help filter songs in compliance with their injunction.

Relatable, an Alexandria, Virginia based company, is a leading provider of advanced content identification and personalization technologies for the digital delivery of audio and video content. Relatable technologies help create a new level of personalized commercial entertainment services.

"Digital fingerprinting technologies are developing rapidly, and Relatable's new acoustic fingerprinting technology shows great promise. We are now working closely with Relatable's engineers to coordinate their technology with our file filtering systems; we hope they will be a substantial part of our overall filtering solution," said Hank Barry, chief executive of Napster.

Napster officials also added that they hope to incorporate Relatable technology into Napster's current file screening system and into a new membership service which can hopefully launch this summer.

April 25 -- Back in September of 1999, the Secure Digital Music Initiative (SDMI) held a $10,000 contest challenging computer pros to hack into copyright protection technologies. Now those computer aces, who foiled four different copyright protection technologies, are being asked by the record companies to suppress their findings.

Professor Edward Felten and his academic hacking group from Princeton University were the ones who answered SDMI's challenge and now they have been threatened with legal action if they go through with plans to reveal how they cracked the anti-piracy codes. The group had planned to reveal the results of their efforts later this week at the Fourth International Information-Hiding Workshop in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania but now those plans are on hold.

Earlier this month, Felten received a letter from SDMI and the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) urging him to refrain from discussing his findings or face potential legal action. "Any disclosure of information gained from participating in the Public Challenge would be outside the scope of activities permitted by the Agreement and could subject you and your research team to actions under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act ..." stated the letter.

SDMI had hoped their challenge was a way to foolproof their anti-piracy efforts before adopting it as an industry wide standard.

May 15 -- Users of the retail version of Windows XP will be required to contact Microsoft when first installing the OS, and on subsequent installations. This is designed as an anti-piracy feature, as it will limit the number of times the software can be installed on different hardware. Microsoft is refusing to tell customers what that cut off point is. Duncan Reid, product services group manager at Microsoft, defended the company's decision, and told silicon.com: "We are not being explicit on details because we don't want to make life easy for unscrupulous hackers."

September 10 -- With the help of Fritz Hollings (D-S.C.), the powerful chairman of the Senate Commerce committee, the RIAA hopes to embed copy-protection controls in nearly all consumer electronic devices and PCs. All types of digital content, including music, video and e-books, are covered. This means radios, televisions, cell phones, basically anything with a microchip inside. Hard drives, CD-ROMs, floppies, you name it. We're not just talking CD Recorders, but anything that receives or uses an electronic signal. TIVO, Satellite TV, Cable,

The Security Systems Standards and Certification Act (SSSCA), scheduled to be introduced by Hollings, backs up this requirement with teeth: It would be a civil offense to create or sell any kind of computer equipment that "does not include and utilize certified security technologies" approved by the federal government. According to the draft, the law would require all digital devices -- computers, software, digital audio and video recorders, digital assistants and electronic book readers -- to prevent unauthorized copying and playback by using security technologies selected by the Secretary of Commerce. The law would require devices to include all certified technologies, not just one, and would require Internet service providers and web sites to store and transmit data with them, too.

It also creates new federal felonies, punishable by five years in prison and fines of up to $500,000. Anyone who distributes copyrighted material with "security measures" disabled or has a network-attached computer that disables copy protection is covered.

Sources

  • Whenever possible, all articles on this page are linked to the source. The chronology of the articles was culled from extensive research in the Boycott-RIAA News Archives.